Logo Design, Is It Worth Paying For?

Chris Rumeau
June 28, 2024
5 minutes

Logo design is incredibly important for a business’ growth. It's the common thread among business owners from any scale, small to large, mom-and-pop to corporate. Every business in the world needs to become visible to attract customers. A logo design is literally the first thing they’ll see and associate with your company. A single glance can decide whether or not they take interest, make an order, visit the store, or engage with your company.

Why Your Business NEEDS a Custom Logo

Logo services are the foundation of a brand’s identity. “Branding” stands for anything that a prospective customer associates with your company when they hear or see its name.

If you’re in the Fitness industry and you’re carrying professional Rogue weight plates and olympic equipment, they’ll associate you with high-end competitive lifting. If you’re a coffee shop and you’re using Starbucks beans openly in front of your customers, rather than artisanal and bespoke roasters like Intelligentsia or Grounds for Change, you’re not going to be associated with quality coffee.

Now consider what your company looks like on its own, apart from its surroundings. All of your customer outreach, all of your advertising, all of your word-of-mouth referrals can start and stop at a poor-looking logo. If it gives an ick, or if people are indifferent to it, you’ve failed to excite or interest them, and you lose them in the marketing process.

Conversely, if you hire a design agency or freelancer and receive a well-thought-out, high-quality logo design (with a full suite of typography, color guides, and everything else you’d need), the effort shows: you’ll stand out from your competition, and the repeat customers you gain will take pride in representing you. You’re effectively building customer recognition and loyalty at the same time!

Logo Design Cost, and You

Logos are creative marketing. They’re an intentional, constructed identity that has its root in being creative and artistic. So, naturally, the price can vary wildly.

A logo design at its lowest pricing is a gamble, and will come from three places: Beginner design software (Canva), race-to-the-bottom markets (Fiverr), or from amateur designers who lowball their prices for work. Sites like Fiverr are fast-moving and don’t take the time to learn about your business. Canva is a great tool for quick design work, but all of your logos are going to be templates, so you’re at high risk of looking exactly the same as another business that uses Canva.

Amateur designers don’t have the grit and experience to understand your business, your “visual competition”, and where you can stand out, but you may find a diamond in the rough, and get lucky with a really talented beginner. These logos can range anywhere from 0 to 500 dollars roughly.

There are medium tier ($600-1500) and higher tier ($3000 to $10,000 or greater) pricing options after this. A great rule of thumb is that the amount of money you put into your logo design is proportional to the value you’ll receive.

Of course if any business had an infinite budget we’d pay for a Nike-level brand experience. You have to balance what your budget will allow, and you will receive a person of proportional experience level. These are people who will take the time to fully understand your business and its context in the market. These are tried and tested designers who know how to distinguish you from anyone else on earth.

These tiers of pricing are where you’ll find the solution, without the gamble, to attract your ideal customers and accelerate your marketing systems.

The Classic Example: Nike

Carolyn Davidson's "first" iteration of the Nike logo

Just do it. Three words. It’s likely that you envisioned a swoosh.

Nike is a reminder that creativity is at the root of logo design, and this work is really dependent on the talent of the person involved. Sometimes that talent is guaranteed by an agency, and sometimes it’s scouted out.

This logomark is so successful at its job that it has become the pillar every company compares itself to, and has global recognition. They took a gamble: Carolyn Davidson designed that logo for $35 while at university. She later received shares in the company for her work. The infamous client feedback to the swoosh:

“I don’t love it, but maybe it’ll grow on me.”

Their swoosh was a strong foundation, and they stayed ahead of the game by associating their brand with progressive movements, actively involving themselves in the culture that they provided shoes and clothing too. A Nike advertisement is still miles ahead of most promotional material, because of the premium they place on good design work.

How to Choose the Right Designer

The right questions, and the right answers. A good designer will have the patience to listen to your story, and be ready to translate that story into a strong visual element. They’ll also be asking you creative but important questions to drive that conversation in a constructive direction. Some of these are pragmatic:

  1. What are some of your competitors either geographically or virtually? (That way, they can plan how to distinguish you from visual competition).
  2. Where do you think your logo will be seen most often? (Designers account for all applications but should be mindful of the most often-used applications for efficacy.)
  3. What are some companies that inspire you visually? (This leads to more conversation on what motivates the company in the first place).

And other questions can be abstract:

  1. What’s your favorite music to listen to? (We sometimes use this if a client has trouble connecting with their creative side. A little bit of what inspires the owner of the business is a LOT of what fuels the ultimate logomark.)
  2. How driven are you towards achieving a good design? (This is to gauge how involved a client would want to be in the process).
  3. What was a significant pushing-point in your business and what’s next for you? (A business owner’s passion is a goldmine for effective design.)

Investing in Your Brand’s Future

I want you to walk away with a few real, gritty facts about making this kind of push for your business. I run a design agency, and I want you as a reader and prospective client of designer work to know these facts of life that I’ve discovered:

  1. WHEN you have the idea to rebrand, or start a brand, act upon it or the world will mysteriously take it from you.
    1. We worked with an sobriety-based athletics event for addiction recovery. We developed a great brand guideline and marketing strategy, but the client didn’t use it for 6 months. In that time: FIVE OTHER COMPANIES were founded and gained momentum with the exact same name and mission statement. Your idea will not wait for you to catch up.
  2. COMPROMISING on logo quality and focusing on budget alone- rather than success- is a direct compromise to the longevity of your company.
    1. Half of the clients we’ve ever taken on have had to start over from a poor designer’s work, typically from Fiverr. You can find good designers on marketplaces, but you have to recognize the hustle they’re undergoing to pay themselves back for such cheap rates. A $50 logo can become thousands lost in uninterested customers.
  3. EFFORT IS RECOGNIZED. In the age of generative AI and easy fixes, genuine effort is a breath of fresh air.
    1. I’m not discouraging AI use. I’m saying: Pick what matters most to you, and truly give that your all. In our case, if you partner with us for effective branding, you will notice that “Brand Activation” will grow your business more gradually than any other strategy.

Rumeau Design Co.

-Chris Rumeau

Chris Rumeau
Rumeau Design Co.
Subscribe
By subscribing you agree to with our Privacy Policy and provide consent to receive updates from our company.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
© 2024 Rumeau Design LLC. All rights reserved.